You Cannot Copy and Paste Leadership Success: You Have to Mimic the Culture You Seek.

By Todd Simmons


In the realm of leadership, success is no longer defined solely by the application of rigid strategies and textbook techniques. The contemporary landscape of organizations demands a more nuanced approach—one that recognizes the indispensable role of a positive and productive organizational culture. A leader’s ability to cultivate such a culture is the cornerstone of their effectiveness. In this dynamic environment, merely copying and pasting leadership practices falls short of true influence. Instead, leaders must immerse themselves deeply in the very culture they seek to foster. Authentic leadership hinges on a profound understanding of an organization’s values, norms, and aspirations. This article explores the compelling concept that effective leaders cannot merely impose change; they must be living embodiments of the desired culture.

The Essence of Organizational Culture

The heart of every organization lies a powerful, yet intangible force known as organizational culture. This intricate tapestry of norms, values, and collective behaviors functions as the silent orchestrator of every interaction and decision within a company. Organizational culture encapsulates the unwritten rules that guide employees, the shared beliefs that shape their attitudes, and the traditions that define how work is approached. In the current landscape of business, characterized by constant change and the demand for innovation, the influence of culture has gained unprecedented prominence.

A company’s culture can spell the difference between triumph and failure, as it informs how teams collaborate, adapt, and navigate challenges. This growing awareness of culture’s paramount significance transcends the conventional role of leadership—it thrusts leaders into the role of cultural architects, responsible not only for strategy and results but also for the very essence that binds the organization together.

The Limitations of Copy-Paste Leadership

In the contemporary landscape of leadership, the allure of quick fixes and universal solutions has given rise to copy-paste leadership—an approach that seeks to replicate successful strategies across diverse organizational settings. In theory, it appears efficient and time-saving, leveraging the readily available wealth of leadership wisdom. Yet, this strategy’s limitations are apparent when faced with the intricate tapestry of organizational cultures.

While it’s tempting to believe that a triumphant leadership model can be transplanted effortlessly, the reality is more nuanced. Each company’s culture is a distinctive ecosystem, shaped by its history, values, and unique dynamics. What flourishes in one environment might wither in another, underscoring the undeniable fact that genuine leadership success cannot be achieved through a one-size-fits-all approach. Authentic leadership isn’t about replication; it’s a personalized expedition that harmonizes with the culture it seeks to influence, recognizing that context matters as much as content.

Embodying Culture: The Core of Authentic Leadership

At the heart of authentic leadership lies the profound concept of embodying organizational culture—a principle that transcends superficial adjustments and delves into the essence of effective leadership. Authentic leaders understand that their role goes beyond mere external changes; it is about immersing themselves deeply within the fabric of the organization. Genuine influence arises when leaders not only advocate for a particular culture but also internalize it in their attitudes and behaviors. This practice entails a thorough grasp of the fundamental values, beliefs, and traditions that define the organization’s identity.

Research underscores that effective leadership is intimately intertwined with the ability to mirror and live out the desired culture. A study conducted by Harvard Business Review highlighted the critical link between leadership authenticity and cultural alignment. The research showed that leaders who authentically embody their organization’s culture engender a sense of trust and loyalty among employees. This authentic alignment cultivates a harmonious work environment where individuals feel a sense of shared purpose and belonging.

Moreover, research published in the Journal of Leadership & Organizational Studies revealed that leaders who actively engage with their organization’s culture by demonstrating its core values in their actions foster higher levels of employee engagement and commitment. By internalizing the culture, they aim to cultivate, leaders serve as role models, setting the tone for the entire workforce and contributing to a cohesive and productive organizational ecosystem.

Understanding the Core Values

 To truly embody the culture, leaders must intimately understand the core values that drive the organization. This requires not only familiarity with the written values but also a comprehension of the unwritten norms and behaviors that define the culture. By aligning their actions with these values, leaders demonstrate authenticity and build trust among their teams.

Leading by Example

 Leading by example stands as a cornerstone of effective leadership, a principle that has been substantiated by extensive research. While not a new concept, its influence remains pivotal in shaping organizational cultures. A study published in the Journal of Applied Psychology found that leaders who consistently model the behaviors and attitudes in line with the desired culture foster a positive climate, employee satisfaction, and commitment. When leaders walk the talk, they provide a tangible benchmark for their teams to emulate, reinforcing cultural norms and expectations. In times of adversity or ambiguity, the significance of leading by example becomes particularly pronounced.

A research article in the Leadership Quarterly highlighted that during periods of uncertainty, employees instinctively turn to leaders for guidance. Leaders who showcase resilience, adaptability, and ethical decision-making through their actions create a sense of stability and inspire confidence, underlining the impact of actions as potent communicators of organizational values and culture.

Empowering Others

Within an organization where a thriving culture prevails, empowerment stands as a central tenet. Leaders who aspire to embody such a culture recognize the paramount significance of not only fostering empowerment but also leading by example in this regard. Appreciating the transformative power of delegation and autonomy, these leaders embrace the practice of entrusting authority to their teams.

By empowering others, leaders demonstrate their belief in the capabilities of their workforce and their commitment to collective growth. This approach not only cultivates a fertile ground for individual development but also imparts a profound sense of ownership and accountability among team members. Empowerment, as mirrored by these leaders, serves as a catalyst for creativity, innovation, and collaboration, reinforcing the interconnectedness between leadership behaviors and the broader organizational culture.


Leadership success is intricately linked to an organization’s culture, and successful leaders recognize that they cannot impose change from the outside. Instead, they must immerse themselves in the culture they seek to cultivate. By understanding and aligning with the values, behaviors, and aspirations of the organization, leaders can shape a thriving and authentic culture. The ten key points discussed here provide a roadmap for leaders to master as they navigate the complex landscape of organizational culture and drive lasting positive change.

About The Author:

Todd Simmons, a seasoned professional with over 30 years of leadership experience, stands as a prominent figure in the realm of leadership and organizational culture. As the Founder of Courageous Leadership Alliance INC., Todd has made significant contributions to the field by sharing his insights and expertise with leading companies around the globe. His dynamic speaking engagements and impactful collaborations have solidified his reputation as a thought leader in building sustainable and impactful organizational cultures.

🔥 Courageous leaders get it done.

Todd Simmons is the Founder of Courageous Leadership Alliance INC. and 25 year Air Force veteran.  

Driven by the mission to serve, Courageous Leadership Alliance was founded in 2019, and has been a leading force dedicated to building courageous leaders.  


Back to Blog Main Page

The RBLP® Blog is a place for contributors to express their views on teamwork, leadership, learning, change, and other topics relevant to the workplace.

Do you have something to say?

Submit your article for consideration.